Phishing Simulation Training: Costs & Scope | Stanfield IT
Colleagues reviewing an example email during security awareness training

Phishing Simulation and Security Awareness Training: Costs and What to Expect

Table of Contents

A phishing simulation is a controlled exercise that tests how people recognise and report a suspicious message. Used well, it helps a business improve everyday behaviour and its response process. It should be part of an ongoing security awareness programme, with clear ownership, safe scenarios and useful follow-up.

For an Australian SME, the value is not a leaderboard showing who clicked. It is knowing whether staff can report a concern, whether the service desk responds correctly and whether payment or account-change procedures hold up when a message looks convincing.

What a phishing simulation should test

Start with the behaviour the business wants to improve. Staff might need to report an unexpected login request, verify a changed bank account through a trusted contact or pause before opening an unusual attachment. The exercise should connect directly with that behaviour.

A campaign can reveal problems beyond individual judgement. Perhaps the reporting button is missing, new starters have not been trained or the service desk does not know how to handle an alert. These are operational findings that management can act on.

Each phishing simulation should use benign content and an approved collection method. Do not collect real passwords, distribute harmful payloads or create a scenario that causes unnecessary distress. Agree how the exercise will be stopped if it disrupts work or creates an unexpected issue.

What should managed security awareness training include?

A managed programme normally needs more than access to a training portal. Agree who maintains the user list, onboards new starters, schedules education, prepares campaigns, reviews results and follows up on problems. A licence can provide tools without supplying those operational responsibilities.

Training should explain the organisation’s actual process. If staff are told to report suspicious email, they need to know which button, address or phone number to use and what happens next. The instructions should also work for people on mobile devices or away from the office.

An initial schedule might combine short monthly learning with quarterly simulations, adjusted to risk and results. Train new starters promptly and revisit important procedures when they change. Agree the cadence with management so exercises remain useful without overwhelming staff.

Use short, relevant learning that fits the roles involved. Finance staff may need additional practice with supplier bank-detail changes. Reception teams may receive unexpected attachments from unfamiliar people every day. Managers need to understand how their own urgent requests can encourage unsafe shortcuts.

Security awareness programme: scope, teach, exercise and improve

Phishing simulation costs: compare the whole service

There is no single useful market price without an agreed scope. Costs depend on the number of people, platform, campaign frequency, onboarding, reporting and the amount of managed follow-up. A per-user licence and a fully managed programme should not be treated as equivalent offers.

Ask each provider to separate setup, recurring subscriptions and ongoing service fees. Confirm minimum commitments, GST, annual versus monthly terms and what happens when staff numbers change. Request a written explanation of anything charged separately, including extra campaigns or specialist incident support.

Cost component What to clarify before accepting a quote
Setup and onboarding User synchronisation, reporting routes, approvals and initial education
Platform subscription Included users, training content, simulations and reporting features
Campaign management Scenario design, scheduling, exclusions and safe delivery configuration
Follow-up and reporting Debriefs, targeted education, management reporting and improvement tracking
Additional support Extra exercises, investigations and work outside the agreed programme

Ask for the first-year total as well as the recurring monthly amount. A clear quote should explain the business responsibilities that remain with you, including approvals, staff communication and decisions about disciplinary matters. Training data should not become an informal employee ranking system.

Can Microsoft 365 provide the platform?

Microsoft’s Attack Simulation Training documentation describes simulations under Defender for Office 365 Plan 2 and eligible Microsoft 365 E5 licensing. Do not assume a Business Premium subscription includes the same capability simply because it contains other Defender protections.

Check existing entitlements before buying another platform, but also compare the service around it. Someone must configure the exercise, manage users, interpret the results and explain the next actions. An included feature can still require implementation and ongoing administration.

For mixed environments or particular training requirements, an alternative platform may be appropriate. The decision should consider reporting, accessibility, user experience and operational fit, alongside licence costs. Confirm the handling and retention of employee information as part of the assessment.

Design a phishing simulation people will trust

Agree the programme with management and the relevant HR or privacy advisers. Tell staff why the business runs exercises, what information is recorded and how results will be used. Exact campaign timing can remain undisclosed without making the overall programme secretive or punitive.

Choose scenarios that reflect realistic threats without exploiting personal hardship. Avoid messages about dismissals, medical emergencies or unexpected financial rewards simply to produce more clicks. A memorable exercise is not necessarily a useful one.

If the exercise identifies a mistake, provide practical feedback promptly. Thank people who report concerns, including those who clicked first and then escalated. A culture that punishes reporting can make a real incident harder to detect and contain.

Measure more than the click rate

Track whether staff reported the message through the correct channel, how quickly a useful report arrived and whether the service desk handled it correctly. Review training participation and recurring process gaps. These measures help connect the exercise to the business’s ability to respond.

Campaign difficulty matters. NIST’s Phish Scale provides a way to consider how challenging a message is to identify. A lower click rate on a much easier message does not establish that staff behaviour improved.

Compare results across suitably comparable campaigns and explain limitations in management reports. Avoid promising a particular reduction in incidents or treating a successful exercise as proof that the business is secure. Real attacks combine people, technology and business processes in ways a simulation cannot fully reproduce.

Phishing exercise measures: reporting, speed, response and learning

What should happen after the exercise?

Turn findings into a short action list with owners and dates. If payment verification was unclear, fix that procedure. If reports were missed, improve the service desk workflow. If a group needs additional support, provide relevant education and a later opportunity to practise.

The programme should sit alongside technical controls such as appropriate email protection, multi-factor authentication, access management and a tested incident response process. Our guide on preventing phishing attacks covers the wider protection required.

Questions to ask before choosing a provider

Ask who approves each phishing simulation, how unsafe scenarios are excluded and who receives individual-level results. Confirm the reporting cadence, follow-up process, data-retention arrangements and ability to stop a campaign. Request a sample management report showing actions and context rather than percentages alone.

A useful provider should be able to explain what will improve in your organisation and how that improvement will be assessed. Stanfield IT’s security awareness training services can help establish a programme that connects education, safe exercises and practical changes to the way your team works.

Experience better IT services

If your IT feels reactive or unclear, we’ll stabilise the essentials and align it to your business goals.

Scroll to Top